Holiday Spending without the January Regret

Written By Ryan Stille

November 17, 2026

Each January the credit card statement arrives, and the autopay account pays off the balance. Groceries, holiday gifts, several nice dinners out with friends and family; they all seem to add up and collapse into one number due in January. So, how does our family avoid the January regret? 

Behavioral finance has a name for spending, the pain of paying. Swiping a credit card is effortless and so much easier than handing over cash. Paying with a debit card provides immediate feedback as monies exit your checking account. It also requires mental gymnastics to figure out how much is left for other expenses.

Credit card usage carries less friction initially which makes it easier to spend your way through the week. Our brain is constantly making decisions throughout the day and looking for short cuts to save energy when possible. Being less “tuned in” to current spending is just another way to make space for more immediate decisions. That’s the allure of credit cards and it can be a slippery slope.

A debit card requires more awareness on what’s available and truly does influence spending behavior. No one enjoys paying overdraft fees, so pausing before purchase creates a speed bump. Slowing down and actively thinking what’s in the checking account before spending originates leads to better financial awareness.

Up to several years ago, my wife and I spent exclusively on our debit card tied to our joint account. This allowed us to keep a handle on what’s there and be more present in our daily spending. This worked as the boys got older, their expenses/activities/summer camps and our household expenses all were managed with precision. But here’s the thing, this takes a lot of energy, discipline, and is rather exhausting! Also, the transfers into our joint account to pay expenses kept increasing as our living expenses inflated. The path of least resistance became using the credit card to cover all expenses with a requirement that the balance would be paid in full the following month. This removed mid-month math calculations and transferring monies into our joint account.

It was and still is the right decision for our family. It works better for us because as we have an understanding on family cashflows and a financial plumbing system leaving us with room for error and opportunity each month. I believe debit cards are the right decision for young adults (our boys) who are figuring out spending, savings, and living. Having an awareness on what’s available to spend helps set yourself up for success as your career and income expand. Equally important, it keeps you from going into debt as you can only spend what’s in your checking account.

What’s happening in our family is life is getting increasingly more expensive, our time availability is shrinking, and family cashflows today just work better via the use of our credit card. Here’s our family’s financial plumbing system that helps us avoid regret in spending all year long. 

Our credit card isn’t a cash reservoir; it’s simply a pipeline to spending

Cash reserves and cashflows must originate somewhere so our spending today and tomorrow can be sustainable. We have an autopay bank account where a bulk of our cash reserves live for monthly spending. Our autopay account handles paying all the big expenses in addition to our investment, savings, and tax account contributions. Mortgage, insurance premiums, active cash savings, investments, estimated Fed taxes, and the credit card bill all are paid from a single account. This does three things:

  • We know on average what it takes to spend/live/give our way through the month
  • We know this monthly number will change which doesn’t surprise us
  • Including estimated Fed taxes gives us a truer sense of net cashflows

Our family’s spending is not linear, it’s lumpy. A large cash reservoir allows us to cover all costs that seem to be evolving month over month. The autopay account is refilled each month via net income to keep water levels high as we navigate the holiday season.

A separate active savings account allows us to save for big ticket expenses, travel, and fun

Our active savings account receives additions each month from the autopay account. Automating this allows us not to think about it and gives us a good feeling we’re saving for tomorrow. We also feel good withdrawing from our active savings account to supplement purchases as needed. A big ticket expense, home renovation, or just something fun our family will enjoy can be covered by our active savings account. The key is adding to and withdrawing from a single account for larger than usual purchases.

My wife and I keep separate checking accounts

Smaller than the autopay and active savings account, these personal checking accounts allow us to spend individually. This covers smaller purchases that a debit card may address. We also keep and refill a smaller joint checking account to cover recurring utilities and other minimal monthly expenses.

We hold more cash reserves than are necessary

Maintaining and checking our liquidity allows us to manage our monies, so our monies don’t manage us. As we invest for our retirement, we don’t need to react when the markets zig and zag and sell at reduced prices to generate cash. Instead, we continue investing through all markets without a need to follow where they are at any given time. I believe this gives our family a strategic advantage that integrates into our financial plan. Cash reserves coupled with a financial plumbing system allows spending today while avoiding regret tomorrow. Money is personal and every family spends money differently.

So, here’s my question for you: how will your family spend for the holidays to avoid the January regret?

Schedule a Chat With Ryan

You May Also Like…